BookmarkSubscribeRSS Feed
🔒 This topic is solved and locked. Need further help from the community? Please sign in and ask a new question.
david27
Quartz | Level 8

Hello @RobPratt :

I am pretty sure I will need you on this.

Thank You for helping newbies like me.

 

I have the below dataset.- Diabetes

For some reason,the constraints are not getting applied.-->>may be I am wrong

Please note: You will have to edit the macro "wpath" for your scenario. I have attached the additional codes here.

Questions:

  • Why does the Solution Status says "Failed"
  • Why does all my weights turn out to be 0?

Because all the weights turn out to be 0 the resulting output(variable nn_output from temp_output dataset) will not be equal to 0 or 1.

It comes write in the middle of 0.5.

This needs to be <0.5 when class =0 and >0.5 when class=1. 

 

 

data diabetes;
infile datalines dlm=",";
input nos_pregnant plasma diastolic triceps insulin bmi dia_pedigree age class ;
datalines;
6,148,72,35,0,33.6,0.627,50,1
1,85,66,29,0,26.6,0.351,31,0
8,183,64,0,0,23.3,0.672,32,1
1,89,66,23,94,28.1,0.167,21,0
0,137,40,35,168,43.1,2.288,33,1
5,116,74,0,0,25.6,0.201,30,0
3,78,50,32,88,31.0,0.248,26,1
10,115,0,0,0,35.3,0.134,29,0
2,197,70,45,543,30.5,0.158,53,1
8,125,96,0,0,0.0,0.232,54,1
4,110,92,0,0,37.6,0.191,30,0
10,168,74,0,0,38.0,0.537,34,1
10,139,80,0,0,27.1,1.441,57,0
1,189,60,23,846,30.1,0.398,59,1
5,166,72,19,175,25.8,0.587,51,1
7,100,0,0,0,30.0,0.484,32,1
0,118,84,47,230,45.8,0.551,31,1
7,107,74,0,0,29.6,0.254,31,1
1,103,30,38,83,43.3,0.183,33,0
1,115,70,30,96,34.6,0.529,32,1
3,126,88,41,235,39.3,0.704,27,0
8,99,84,0,0,35.4,0.388,50,0
7,196,90,0,0,39.8,0.451,41,1
9,119,80,35,0,29.0,0.263,29,1
11,143,94,33,146,36.6,0.254,51,1
10,125,70,26,115,31.1,0.205,41,1
7,147,76,0,0,39.4,0.257,43,1
1,97,66,15,140,23.2,0.487,22,0
13,145,82,19,110,22.2,0.245,57,0
5,117,92,0,0,34.1,0.337,38,0
5,109,75,26,0,36.0,0.546,60,0
3,158,76,36,245,31.6,0.851,28,1
3,88,58,11,54,24.8,0.267,22,0
6,92,92,0,0,19.9,0.188,28,0
10,122,78,31,0,27.6,0.512,45,0
4,103,60,33,192,24.0,0.966,33,0
11,138,76,0,0,33.2,0.420,35,0
9,102,76,37,0,32.9,0.665,46,1
2,90,68,42,0,38.2,0.503,27,1
4,111,72,47,207,37.1,1.390,56,1
3,180,64,25,70,34.0,0.271,26,0
7,133,84,0,0,40.2,0.696,37,0
7,106,92,18,0,22.7,0.235,48,0
9,171,110,24,240,45.4,0.721,54,1
7,159,64,0,0,27.4,0.294,40,0
0,180,66,39,0,42.0,1.893,25,1
1,146,56,0,0,29.7,0.564,29,0
2,71,70,27,0,28.0,0.586,22,0
7,103,66,32,0,39.1,0.344,31,1
7,105,0,0,0,0.0,0.305,24,0
1,103,80,11,82,19.4,0.491,22,0
1,101,50,15,36,24.2,0.526,26,0
5,88,66,21,23,24.4,0.342,30,0
8,176,90,34,300,33.7,0.467,58,1
7,150,66,42,342,34.7,0.718,42,0
1,73,50,10,0,23.0,0.248,21,0
7,187,68,39,304,37.7,0.254,41,1
0,100,88,60,110,46.8,0.962,31,0
0,146,82,0,0,40.5,1.781,44,0
0,105,64,41,142,41.5,0.173,22,0
2,84,0,0,0,0.0,0.304,21,0
8,133,72,0,0,32.9,0.270,39,1
5,44,62,0,0,25.0,0.587,36,0
2,141,58,34,128,25.4,0.699,24,0
7,114,66,0,0,32.8,0.258,42,1
5,99,74,27,0,29.0,0.203,32,0
0,109,88,30,0,32.5,0.855,38,1
2,109,92,0,0,42.7,0.845,54,0
1,95,66,13,38,19.6,0.334,25,0
4,146,85,27,100,28.9,0.189,27,0
2,100,66,20,90,32.9,0.867,28,1
5,139,64,35,140,28.6,0.411,26,0
13,126,90,0,0,43.4,0.583,42,1
4,129,86,20,270,35.1,0.231,23,0
1,79,75,30,0,32.0,0.396,22,0
1,0,48,20,0,24.7,0.140,22,0
7,62,78,0,0,32.6,0.391,41,0
5,95,72,33,0,37.7,0.370,27,0
0,131,0,0,0,43.2,0.270,26,1
2,112,66,22,0,25.0,0.307,24,0
3,113,44,13,0,22.4,0.140,22,0
2,74,0,0,0,0.0,0.102,22,0
7,83,78,26,71,29.3,0.767,36,0
0,101,65,28,0,24.6,0.237,22,0
5,137,108,0,0,48.8,0.227,37,1
2,110,74,29,125,32.4,0.698,27,0
13,106,72,54,0,36.6,0.178,45,0
2,100,68,25,71,38.5,0.324,26,0
15,136,70,32,110,37.1,0.153,43,1
1,107,68,19,0,26.5,0.165,24,0
1,80,55,0,0,19.1,0.258,21,0
4,123,80,15,176,32.0,0.443,34,0
7,81,78,40,48,46.7,0.261,42,0
4,134,72,0,0,23.8,0.277,60,1
2,142,82,18,64,24.7,0.761,21,0
6,144,72,27,228,33.9,0.255,40,0
2,92,62,28,0,31.6,0.130,24,0
1,71,48,18,76,20.4,0.323,22,0
6,93,50,30,64,28.7,0.356,23,0
1,122,90,51,220,49.7,0.325,31,1
1,163,72,0,0,39.0,1.222,33,1
1,151,60,0,0,26.1,0.179,22,0
0,125,96,0,0,22.5,0.262,21,0
1,81,72,18,40,26.6,0.283,24,0
2,85,65,0,0,39.6,0.930,27,0
1,126,56,29,152,28.7,0.801,21,0
1,96,122,0,0,22.4,0.207,27,0
4,144,58,28,140,29.5,0.287,37,0
3,83,58,31,18,34.3,0.336,25,0
0,95,85,25,36,37.4,0.247,24,1
3,171,72,33,135,33.3,0.199,24,1
8,155,62,26,495,34.0,0.543,46,1
1,89,76,34,37,31.2,0.192,23,0
4,76,62,0,0,34.0,0.391,25,0
7,160,54,32,175,30.5,0.588,39,1
4,146,92,0,0,31.2,0.539,61,1
5,124,74,0,0,34.0,0.220,38,1
5,78,48,0,0,33.7,0.654,25,0
4,97,60,23,0,28.2,0.443,22,0
4,99,76,15,51,23.2,0.223,21,0
0,162,76,56,100,53.2,0.759,25,1
6,111,64,39,0,34.2,0.260,24,0
2,107,74,30,100,33.6,0.404,23,0
5,132,80,0,0,26.8,0.186,69,0
0,113,76,0,0,33.3,0.278,23,1
1,88,30,42,99,55.0,0.496,26,1
3,120,70,30,135,42.9,0.452,30,0
1,118,58,36,94,33.3,0.261,23,0
1,117,88,24,145,34.5,0.403,40,1
0,105,84,0,0,27.9,0.741,62,1
4,173,70,14,168,29.7,0.361,33,1
9,122,56,0,0,33.3,1.114,33,1
3,170,64,37,225,34.5,0.356,30,1
8,84,74,31,0,38.3,0.457,39,0
2,96,68,13,49,21.1,0.647,26,0
2,125,60,20,140,33.8,0.088,31,0
0,100,70,26,50,30.8,0.597,21,0
0,93,60,25,92,28.7,0.532,22,0
0,129,80,0,0,31.2,0.703,29,0
5,105,72,29,325,36.9,0.159,28,0
3,128,78,0,0,21.1,0.268,55,0
5,106,82,30,0,39.5,0.286,38,0
2,108,52,26,63,32.5,0.318,22,0
10,108,66,0,0,32.4,0.272,42,1
4,154,62,31,284,32.8,0.237,23,0
0,102,75,23,0,0.0,0.572,21,0
9,57,80,37,0,32.8,0.096,41,0
2,106,64,35,119,30.5,1.400,34,0
5,147,78,0,0,33.7,0.218,65,0
2,90,70,17,0,27.3,0.085,22,0
1,136,74,50,204,37.4,0.399,24,0
4,114,65,0,0,21.9,0.432,37,0
9,156,86,28,155,34.3,1.189,42,1
1,153,82,42,485,40.6,0.687,23,0
8,188,78,0,0,47.9,0.137,43,1
7,152,88,44,0,50.0,0.337,36,1
2,99,52,15,94,24.6,0.637,21,0
1,109,56,21,135,25.2,0.833,23,0
2,88,74,19,53,29.0,0.229,22,0
17,163,72,41,114,40.9,0.817,47,1
4,151,90,38,0,29.7,0.294,36,0
7,102,74,40,105,37.2,0.204,45,0
0,114,80,34,285,44.2,0.167,27,0
2,100,64,23,0,29.7,0.368,21,0
0,131,88,0,0,31.6,0.743,32,1
6,104,74,18,156,29.9,0.722,41,1
3,148,66,25,0,32.5,0.256,22,0
4,120,68,0,0,29.6,0.709,34,0
4,110,66,0,0,31.9,0.471,29,0
3,111,90,12,78,28.4,0.495,29,0
6,102,82,0,0,30.8,0.180,36,1
6,134,70,23,130,35.4,0.542,29,1
2,87,0,23,0,28.9,0.773,25,0
1,79,60,42,48,43.5,0.678,23,0
2,75,64,24,55,29.7,0.370,33,0
8,179,72,42,130,32.7,0.719,36,1
6,85,78,0,0,31.2,0.382,42,0
0,129,110,46,130,67.1,0.319,26,1
5,143,78,0,0,45.0,0.190,47,0
5,130,82,0,0,39.1,0.956,37,1
6,87,80,0,0,23.2,0.084,32,0
0,119,64,18,92,34.9,0.725,23,0
1,0,74,20,23,27.7,0.299,21,0
5,73,60,0,0,26.8,0.268,27,0
4,141,74,0,0,27.6,0.244,40,0
7,194,68,28,0,35.9,0.745,41,1
8,181,68,36,495,30.1,0.615,60,1
1,128,98,41,58,32.0,1.321,33,1
8,109,76,39,114,27.9,0.640,31,1
5,139,80,35,160,31.6,0.361,25,1
3,111,62,0,0,22.6,0.142,21,0
9,123,70,44,94,33.1,0.374,40,0
7,159,66,0,0,30.4,0.383,36,1
11,135,0,0,0,52.3,0.578,40,1
8,85,55,20,0,24.4,0.136,42,0
5,158,84,41,210,39.4,0.395,29,1
1,105,58,0,0,24.3,0.187,21,0
3,107,62,13,48,22.9,0.678,23,1
4,109,64,44,99,34.8,0.905,26,1
4,148,60,27,318,30.9,0.150,29,1
0,113,80,16,0,31.0,0.874,21,0
1,138,82,0,0,40.1,0.236,28,0
0,108,68,20,0,27.3,0.787,32,0
2,99,70,16,44,20.4,0.235,27,0
6,103,72,32,190,37.7,0.324,55,0
5,111,72,28,0,23.9,0.407,27,0
8,196,76,29,280,37.5,0.605,57,1
5,162,104,0,0,37.7,0.151,52,1
1,96,64,27,87,33.2,0.289,21,0
7,184,84,33,0,35.5,0.355,41,1
2,81,60,22,0,27.7,0.290,25,0
0,147,85,54,0,42.8,0.375,24,0
7,179,95,31,0,34.2,0.164,60,0
0,140,65,26,130,42.6,0.431,24,1
9,112,82,32,175,34.2,0.260,36,1
12,151,70,40,271,41.8,0.742,38,1
5,109,62,41,129,35.8,0.514,25,1
6,125,68,30,120,30.0,0.464,32,0
5,85,74,22,0,29.0,1.224,32,1
5,112,66,0,0,37.8,0.261,41,1
0,177,60,29,478,34.6,1.072,21,1
2,158,90,0,0,31.6,0.805,66,1
7,119,0,0,0,25.2,0.209,37,0
7,142,60,33,190,28.8,0.687,61,0
1,100,66,15,56,23.6,0.666,26,0
1,87,78,27,32,34.6,0.101,22,0
0,101,76,0,0,35.7,0.198,26,0
3,162,52,38,0,37.2,0.652,24,1
4,197,70,39,744,36.7,2.329,31,0
0,117,80,31,53,45.2,0.089,24,0
4,142,86,0,0,44.0,0.645,22,1
6,134,80,37,370,46.2,0.238,46,1
1,79,80,25,37,25.4,0.583,22,0
4,122,68,0,0,35.0,0.394,29,0
3,74,68,28,45,29.7,0.293,23,0
4,171,72,0,0,43.6,0.479,26,1
7,181,84,21,192,35.9,0.586,51,1
0,179,90,27,0,44.1,0.686,23,1
9,164,84,21,0,30.8,0.831,32,1
0,104,76,0,0,18.4,0.582,27,0
1,91,64,24,0,29.2,0.192,21,0
4,91,70,32,88,33.1,0.446,22,0
3,139,54,0,0,25.6,0.402,22,1
6,119,50,22,176,27.1,1.318,33,1
2,146,76,35,194,38.2,0.329,29,0
9,184,85,15,0,30.0,1.213,49,1
10,122,68,0,0,31.2,0.258,41,0
0,165,90,33,680,52.3,0.427,23,0
9,124,70,33,402,35.4,0.282,34,0
1,111,86,19,0,30.1,0.143,23,0
9,106,52,0,0,31.2,0.380,42,0
2,129,84,0,0,28.0,0.284,27,0
2,90,80,14,55,24.4,0.249,24,0
0,86,68,32,0,35.8,0.238,25,0
12,92,62,7,258,27.6,0.926,44,1
1,113,64,35,0,33.6,0.543,21,1
3,111,56,39,0,30.1,0.557,30,0
2,114,68,22,0,28.7,0.092,25,0
1,193,50,16,375,25.9,0.655,24,0
11,155,76,28,150,33.3,1.353,51,1
3,191,68,15,130,30.9,0.299,34,0
3,141,0,0,0,30.0,0.761,27,1
4,95,70,32,0,32.1,0.612,24,0
3,142,80,15,0,32.4,0.200,63,0
4,123,62,0,0,32.0,0.226,35,1
5,96,74,18,67,33.6,0.997,43,0
0,138,0,0,0,36.3,0.933,25,1
2,128,64,42,0,40.0,1.101,24,0
0,102,52,0,0,25.1,0.078,21,0
2,146,0,0,0,27.5,0.240,28,1
10,101,86,37,0,45.6,1.136,38,1
2,108,62,32,56,25.2,0.128,21,0
3,122,78,0,0,23.0,0.254,40,0
1,71,78,50,45,33.2,0.422,21,0
13,106,70,0,0,34.2,0.251,52,0
2,100,70,52,57,40.5,0.677,25,0
7,106,60,24,0,26.5,0.296,29,1
0,104,64,23,116,27.8,0.454,23,0
5,114,74,0,0,24.9,0.744,57,0
2,108,62,10,278,25.3,0.881,22,0
0,146,70,0,0,37.9,0.334,28,1
10,129,76,28,122,35.9,0.280,39,0
7,133,88,15,155,32.4,0.262,37,0
7,161,86,0,0,30.4,0.165,47,1
2,108,80,0,0,27.0,0.259,52,1
7,136,74,26,135,26.0,0.647,51,0
5,155,84,44,545,38.7,0.619,34,0
1,119,86,39,220,45.6,0.808,29,1
4,96,56,17,49,20.8,0.340,26,0
5,108,72,43,75,36.1,0.263,33,0
0,78,88,29,40,36.9,0.434,21,0
0,107,62,30,74,36.6,0.757,25,1
2,128,78,37,182,43.3,1.224,31,1
1,128,48,45,194,40.5,0.613,24,1
0,161,50,0,0,21.9,0.254,65,0
6,151,62,31,120,35.5,0.692,28,0
2,146,70,38,360,28.0,0.337,29,1
0,126,84,29,215,30.7,0.520,24,0
14,100,78,25,184,36.6,0.412,46,1
8,112,72,0,0,23.6,0.840,58,0
0,167,0,0,0,32.3,0.839,30,1
2,144,58,33,135,31.6,0.422,25,1
5,77,82,41,42,35.8,0.156,35,0
5,115,98,0,0,52.9,0.209,28,1
3,150,76,0,0,21.0,0.207,37,0
2,120,76,37,105,39.7,0.215,29,0
10,161,68,23,132,25.5,0.326,47,1
0,137,68,14,148,24.8,0.143,21,0
0,128,68,19,180,30.5,1.391,25,1
2,124,68,28,205,32.9,0.875,30,1
6,80,66,30,0,26.2,0.313,41,0
0,106,70,37,148,39.4,0.605,22,0
2,155,74,17,96,26.6,0.433,27,1
3,113,50,10,85,29.5,0.626,25,0
7,109,80,31,0,35.9,1.127,43,1
2,112,68,22,94,34.1,0.315,26,0
3,99,80,11,64,19.3,0.284,30,0
3,182,74,0,0,30.5,0.345,29,1
3,115,66,39,140,38.1,0.150,28,0
6,194,78,0,0,23.5,0.129,59,1
4,129,60,12,231,27.5,0.527,31,0
3,112,74,30,0,31.6,0.197,25,1
0,124,70,20,0,27.4,0.254,36,1
13,152,90,33,29,26.8,0.731,43,1
2,112,75,32,0,35.7,0.148,21,0
1,157,72,21,168,25.6,0.123,24,0
1,122,64,32,156,35.1,0.692,30,1
10,179,70,0,0,35.1,0.200,37,0
2,102,86,36,120,45.5,0.127,23,1
6,105,70,32,68,30.8,0.122,37,0
8,118,72,19,0,23.1,1.476,46,0
2,87,58,16,52,32.7,0.166,25,0
1,180,0,0,0,43.3,0.282,41,1
12,106,80,0,0,23.6,0.137,44,0
1,95,60,18,58,23.9,0.260,22,0
0,165,76,43,255,47.9,0.259,26,0
0,117,0,0,0,33.8,0.932,44,0
5,115,76,0,0,31.2,0.343,44,1
9,152,78,34,171,34.2,0.893,33,1
7,178,84,0,0,39.9,0.331,41,1
1,130,70,13,105,25.9,0.472,22,0
1,95,74,21,73,25.9,0.673,36,0
1,0,68,35,0,32.0,0.389,22,0
5,122,86,0,0,34.7,0.290,33,0
8,95,72,0,0,36.8,0.485,57,0
8,126,88,36,108,38.5,0.349,49,0
1,139,46,19,83,28.7,0.654,22,0
3,116,0,0,0,23.5,0.187,23,0
3,99,62,19,74,21.8,0.279,26,0
5,0,80,32,0,41.0,0.346,37,1
4,92,80,0,0,42.2,0.237,29,0
4,137,84,0,0,31.2,0.252,30,0
3,61,82,28,0,34.4,0.243,46,0
1,90,62,12,43,27.2,0.580,24,0
3,90,78,0,0,42.7,0.559,21,0
9,165,88,0,0,30.4,0.302,49,1
1,125,50,40,167,33.3,0.962,28,1
13,129,0,30,0,39.9,0.569,44,1
12,88,74,40,54,35.3,0.378,48,0
1,196,76,36,249,36.5,0.875,29,1
5,189,64,33,325,31.2,0.583,29,1
5,158,70,0,0,29.8,0.207,63,0
5,103,108,37,0,39.2,0.305,65,0
4,146,78,0,0,38.5,0.520,67,1
4,147,74,25,293,34.9,0.385,30,0
5,99,54,28,83,34.0,0.499,30,0
6,124,72,0,0,27.6,0.368,29,1
0,101,64,17,0,21.0,0.252,21,0
3,81,86,16,66,27.5,0.306,22,0
1,133,102,28,140,32.8,0.234,45,1
3,173,82,48,465,38.4,2.137,25,1
0,118,64,23,89,0.0,1.731,21,0
0,84,64,22,66,35.8,0.545,21,0
2,105,58,40,94,34.9,0.225,25,0
2,122,52,43,158,36.2,0.816,28,0
12,140,82,43,325,39.2,0.528,58,1
0,98,82,15,84,25.2,0.299,22,0
1,87,60,37,75,37.2,0.509,22,0
4,156,75,0,0,48.3,0.238,32,1
0,93,100,39,72,43.4,1.021,35,0
1,107,72,30,82,30.8,0.821,24,0
0,105,68,22,0,20.0,0.236,22,0
1,109,60,8,182,25.4,0.947,21,0
1,90,62,18,59,25.1,1.268,25,0
1,125,70,24,110,24.3,0.221,25,0
1,119,54,13,50,22.3,0.205,24,0
5,116,74,29,0,32.3,0.660,35,1
8,105,100,36,0,43.3,0.239,45,1
5,144,82,26,285,32.0,0.452,58,1
3,100,68,23,81,31.6,0.949,28,0
1,100,66,29,196,32.0,0.444,42,0
5,166,76,0,0,45.7,0.340,27,1
1,131,64,14,415,23.7,0.389,21,0
4,116,72,12,87,22.1,0.463,37,0
4,158,78,0,0,32.9,0.803,31,1
2,127,58,24,275,27.7,1.600,25,0
3,96,56,34,115,24.7,0.944,39,0
0,131,66,40,0,34.3,0.196,22,1
3,82,70,0,0,21.1,0.389,25,0
3,193,70,31,0,34.9,0.241,25,1
4,95,64,0,0,32.0,0.161,31,1
6,137,61,0,0,24.2,0.151,55,0
5,136,84,41,88,35.0,0.286,35,1
9,72,78,25,0,31.6,0.280,38,0
5,168,64,0,0,32.9,0.135,41,1
2,123,48,32,165,42.1,0.520,26,0
4,115,72,0,0,28.9,0.376,46,1
0,101,62,0,0,21.9,0.336,25,0
8,197,74,0,0,25.9,1.191,39,1
1,172,68,49,579,42.4,0.702,28,1
6,102,90,39,0,35.7,0.674,28,0
1,112,72,30,176,34.4,0.528,25,0
1,143,84,23,310,42.4,1.076,22,0
1,143,74,22,61,26.2,0.256,21,0
0,138,60,35,167,34.6,0.534,21,1
3,173,84,33,474,35.7,0.258,22,1
1,97,68,21,0,27.2,1.095,22,0
4,144,82,32,0,38.5,0.554,37,1
1,83,68,0,0,18.2,0.624,27,0
3,129,64,29,115,26.4,0.219,28,1
1,119,88,41,170,45.3,0.507,26,0
2,94,68,18,76,26.0,0.561,21,0
0,102,64,46,78,40.6,0.496,21,0
2,115,64,22,0,30.8,0.421,21,0
8,151,78,32,210,42.9,0.516,36,1
4,184,78,39,277,37.0,0.264,31,1
0,94,0,0,0,0.0,0.256,25,0
1,181,64,30,180,34.1,0.328,38,1
0,135,94,46,145,40.6,0.284,26,0
1,95,82,25,180,35.0,0.233,43,1
2,99,0,0,0,22.2,0.108,23,0
3,89,74,16,85,30.4,0.551,38,0
1,80,74,11,60,30.0,0.527,22,0
2,139,75,0,0,25.6,0.167,29,0
1,90,68,8,0,24.5,1.138,36,0
0,141,0,0,0,42.4,0.205,29,1
12,140,85,33,0,37.4,0.244,41,0
5,147,75,0,0,29.9,0.434,28,0
1,97,70,15,0,18.2,0.147,21,0
6,107,88,0,0,36.8,0.727,31,0
0,189,104,25,0,34.3,0.435,41,1
2,83,66,23,50,32.2,0.497,22,0
4,117,64,27,120,33.2,0.230,24,0
8,108,70,0,0,30.5,0.955,33,1
4,117,62,12,0,29.7,0.380,30,1
0,180,78,63,14,59.4,2.420,25,1
1,100,72,12,70,25.3,0.658,28,0
0,95,80,45,92,36.5,0.330,26,0
0,104,64,37,64,33.6,0.510,22,1
0,120,74,18,63,30.5,0.285,26,0
1,82,64,13,95,21.2,0.415,23,0
2,134,70,0,0,28.9,0.542,23,1
0,91,68,32,210,39.9,0.381,25,0
2,119,0,0,0,19.6,0.832,72,0
2,100,54,28,105,37.8,0.498,24,0
14,175,62,30,0,33.6,0.212,38,1
1,135,54,0,0,26.7,0.687,62,0
5,86,68,28,71,30.2,0.364,24,0
10,148,84,48,237,37.6,1.001,51,1
9,134,74,33,60,25.9,0.460,81,0
9,120,72,22,56,20.8,0.733,48,0
1,71,62,0,0,21.8,0.416,26,0
8,74,70,40,49,35.3,0.705,39,0
5,88,78,30,0,27.6,0.258,37,0
10,115,98,0,0,24.0,1.022,34,0
0,124,56,13,105,21.8,0.452,21,0
0,74,52,10,36,27.8,0.269,22,0
0,97,64,36,100,36.8,0.600,25,0
8,120,0,0,0,30.0,0.183,38,1
6,154,78,41,140,46.1,0.571,27,0
1,144,82,40,0,41.3,0.607,28,0
0,137,70,38,0,33.2,0.170,22,0
0,119,66,27,0,38.8,0.259,22,0
7,136,90,0,0,29.9,0.210,50,0
4,114,64,0,0,28.9,0.126,24,0
0,137,84,27,0,27.3,0.231,59,0
2,105,80,45,191,33.7,0.711,29,1
7,114,76,17,110,23.8,0.466,31,0
8,126,74,38,75,25.9,0.162,39,0
4,132,86,31,0,28.0,0.419,63,0
3,158,70,30,328,35.5,0.344,35,1
0,123,88,37,0,35.2,0.197,29,0
4,85,58,22,49,27.8,0.306,28,0
0,84,82,31,125,38.2,0.233,23,0
0,145,0,0,0,44.2,0.630,31,1
0,135,68,42,250,42.3,0.365,24,1
1,139,62,41,480,40.7,0.536,21,0
0,173,78,32,265,46.5,1.159,58,0
4,99,72,17,0,25.6,0.294,28,0
8,194,80,0,0,26.1,0.551,67,0
2,83,65,28,66,36.8,0.629,24,0
2,89,90,30,0,33.5,0.292,42,0
4,99,68,38,0,32.8,0.145,33,0
4,125,70,18,122,28.9,1.144,45,1
3,80,0,0,0,0.0,0.174,22,0
6,166,74,0,0,26.6,0.304,66,0
5,110,68,0,0,26.0,0.292,30,0
2,81,72,15,76,30.1,0.547,25,0
7,195,70,33,145,25.1,0.163,55,1
6,154,74,32,193,29.3,0.839,39,0
2,117,90,19,71,25.2,0.313,21,0
3,84,72,32,0,37.2,0.267,28,0
6,0,68,41,0,39.0,0.727,41,1
7,94,64,25,79,33.3,0.738,41,0
3,96,78,39,0,37.3,0.238,40,0
10,75,82,0,0,33.3,0.263,38,0
0,180,90,26,90,36.5,0.314,35,1
1,130,60,23,170,28.6,0.692,21,0
2,84,50,23,76,30.4,0.968,21,0
8,120,78,0,0,25.0,0.409,64,0
12,84,72,31,0,29.7,0.297,46,1
0,139,62,17,210,22.1,0.207,21,0
9,91,68,0,0,24.2,0.200,58,0
2,91,62,0,0,27.3,0.525,22,0
3,99,54,19,86,25.6,0.154,24,0
3,163,70,18,105,31.6,0.268,28,1
9,145,88,34,165,30.3,0.771,53,1
7,125,86,0,0,37.6,0.304,51,0
13,76,60,0,0,32.8,0.180,41,0
6,129,90,7,326,19.6,0.582,60,0
2,68,70,32,66,25.0,0.187,25,0
3,124,80,33,130,33.2,0.305,26,0
6,114,0,0,0,0.0,0.189,26,0
9,130,70,0,0,34.2,0.652,45,1
3,125,58,0,0,31.6,0.151,24,0
3,87,60,18,0,21.8,0.444,21,0
1,97,64,19,82,18.2,0.299,21,0
3,116,74,15,105,26.3,0.107,24,0
0,117,66,31,188,30.8,0.493,22,0
0,111,65,0,0,24.6,0.660,31,0
2,122,60,18,106,29.8,0.717,22,0
0,107,76,0,0,45.3,0.686,24,0
1,86,66,52,65,41.3,0.917,29,0
6,91,0,0,0,29.8,0.501,31,0
1,77,56,30,56,33.3,1.251,24,0
4,132,0,0,0,32.9,0.302,23,1
0,105,90,0,0,29.6,0.197,46,0
0,57,60,0,0,21.7,0.735,67,0
0,127,80,37,210,36.3,0.804,23,0
3,129,92,49,155,36.4,0.968,32,1
8,100,74,40,215,39.4,0.661,43,1
3,128,72,25,190,32.4,0.549,27,1
10,90,85,32,0,34.9,0.825,56,1
4,84,90,23,56,39.5,0.159,25,0
1,88,78,29,76,32.0,0.365,29,0
8,186,90,35,225,34.5,0.423,37,1
5,187,76,27,207,43.6,1.034,53,1
4,131,68,21,166,33.1,0.160,28,0
1,164,82,43,67,32.8,0.341,50,0
4,189,110,31,0,28.5,0.680,37,0
1,116,70,28,0,27.4,0.204,21,0
3,84,68,30,106,31.9,0.591,25,0
6,114,88,0,0,27.8,0.247,66,0
1,88,62,24,44,29.9,0.422,23,0
1,84,64,23,115,36.9,0.471,28,0
7,124,70,33,215,25.5,0.161,37,0
1,97,70,40,0,38.1,0.218,30,0
8,110,76,0,0,27.8,0.237,58,0
11,103,68,40,0,46.2,0.126,42,0
11,85,74,0,0,30.1,0.300,35,0
6,125,76,0,0,33.8,0.121,54,1
0,198,66,32,274,41.3,0.502,28,1
1,87,68,34,77,37.6,0.401,24,0
6,99,60,19,54,26.9,0.497,32,0
0,91,80,0,0,32.4,0.601,27,0
2,95,54,14,88,26.1,0.748,22,0
1,99,72,30,18,38.6,0.412,21,0
6,92,62,32,126,32.0,0.085,46,0
4,154,72,29,126,31.3,0.338,37,0
0,121,66,30,165,34.3,0.203,33,1
3,78,70,0,0,32.5,0.270,39,0
2,130,96,0,0,22.6,0.268,21,0
3,111,58,31,44,29.5,0.430,22,0
2,98,60,17,120,34.7,0.198,22,0
1,143,86,30,330,30.1,0.892,23,0
1,119,44,47,63,35.5,0.280,25,0
6,108,44,20,130,24.0,0.813,35,0
2,118,80,0,0,42.9,0.693,21,1
10,133,68,0,0,27.0,0.245,36,0
2,197,70,99,0,34.7,0.575,62,1
0,151,90,46,0,42.1,0.371,21,1
6,109,60,27,0,25.0,0.206,27,0
12,121,78,17,0,26.5,0.259,62,0
8,100,76,0,0,38.7,0.190,42,0
8,124,76,24,600,28.7,0.687,52,1
1,93,56,11,0,22.5,0.417,22,0
8,143,66,0,0,34.9,0.129,41,1
6,103,66,0,0,24.3,0.249,29,0
3,176,86,27,156,33.3,1.154,52,1
0,73,0,0,0,21.1,0.342,25,0
11,111,84,40,0,46.8,0.925,45,1
2,112,78,50,140,39.4,0.175,24,0
3,132,80,0,0,34.4,0.402,44,1
2,82,52,22,115,28.5,1.699,25,0
6,123,72,45,230,33.6,0.733,34,0
0,188,82,14,185,32.0,0.682,22,1
0,67,76,0,0,45.3,0.194,46,0
1,89,24,19,25,27.8,0.559,21,0
1,173,74,0,0,36.8,0.088,38,1
1,109,38,18,120,23.1,0.407,26,0
1,108,88,19,0,27.1,0.400,24,0
6,96,0,0,0,23.7,0.190,28,0
1,124,74,36,0,27.8,0.100,30,0
7,150,78,29,126,35.2,0.692,54,1
4,183,0,0,0,28.4,0.212,36,1
1,124,60,32,0,35.8,0.514,21,0
1,181,78,42,293,40.0,1.258,22,1
1,92,62,25,41,19.5,0.482,25,0
0,152,82,39,272,41.5,0.270,27,0
1,111,62,13,182,24.0,0.138,23,0
3,106,54,21,158,30.9,0.292,24,0
3,174,58,22,194,32.9,0.593,36,1
7,168,88,42,321,38.2,0.787,40,1
6,105,80,28,0,32.5,0.878,26,0
11,138,74,26,144,36.1,0.557,50,1
3,106,72,0,0,25.8,0.207,27,0
6,117,96,0,0,28.7,0.157,30,0
2,68,62,13,15,20.1,0.257,23,0
9,112,82,24,0,28.2,1.282,50,1
0,119,0,0,0,32.4,0.141,24,1
2,112,86,42,160,38.4,0.246,28,0
2,92,76,20,0,24.2,1.698,28,0
6,183,94,0,0,40.8,1.461,45,0
0,94,70,27,115,43.5,0.347,21,0
2,108,64,0,0,30.8,0.158,21,0
4,90,88,47,54,37.7,0.362,29,0
0,125,68,0,0,24.7,0.206,21,0
0,132,78,0,0,32.4,0.393,21,0
5,128,80,0,0,34.6,0.144,45,0
4,94,65,22,0,24.7,0.148,21,0
7,114,64,0,0,27.4,0.732,34,1
0,102,78,40,90,34.5,0.238,24,0
2,111,60,0,0,26.2,0.343,23,0
1,128,82,17,183,27.5,0.115,22,0
10,92,62,0,0,25.9,0.167,31,0
13,104,72,0,0,31.2,0.465,38,1
5,104,74,0,0,28.8,0.153,48,0
2,94,76,18,66,31.6,0.649,23,0
7,97,76,32,91,40.9,0.871,32,1
1,100,74,12,46,19.5,0.149,28,0
0,102,86,17,105,29.3,0.695,27,0
4,128,70,0,0,34.3,0.303,24,0
6,147,80,0,0,29.5,0.178,50,1
4,90,0,0,0,28.0,0.610,31,0
3,103,72,30,152,27.6,0.730,27,0
2,157,74,35,440,39.4,0.134,30,0
1,167,74,17,144,23.4,0.447,33,1
0,179,50,36,159,37.8,0.455,22,1
11,136,84,35,130,28.3,0.260,42,1
0,107,60,25,0,26.4,0.133,23,0
1,91,54,25,100,25.2,0.234,23,0
1,117,60,23,106,33.8,0.466,27,0
5,123,74,40,77,34.1,0.269,28,0
2,120,54,0,0,26.8,0.455,27,0
1,106,70,28,135,34.2,0.142,22,0
2,155,52,27,540,38.7,0.240,25,1
2,101,58,35,90,21.8,0.155,22,0
1,120,80,48,200,38.9,1.162,41,0
11,127,106,0,0,39.0,0.190,51,0
3,80,82,31,70,34.2,1.292,27,1
10,162,84,0,0,27.7,0.182,54,0
1,199,76,43,0,42.9,1.394,22,1
8,167,106,46,231,37.6,0.165,43,1
9,145,80,46,130,37.9,0.637,40,1
6,115,60,39,0,33.7,0.245,40,1
1,112,80,45,132,34.8,0.217,24,0
4,145,82,18,0,32.5,0.235,70,1
10,111,70,27,0,27.5,0.141,40,1
6,98,58,33,190,34.0,0.430,43,0
9,154,78,30,100,30.9,0.164,45,0
6,165,68,26,168,33.6,0.631,49,0
1,99,58,10,0,25.4,0.551,21,0
10,68,106,23,49,35.5,0.285,47,0
3,123,100,35,240,57.3,0.880,22,0
8,91,82,0,0,35.6,0.587,68,0
6,195,70,0,0,30.9,0.328,31,1
9,156,86,0,0,24.8,0.230,53,1
0,93,60,0,0,35.3,0.263,25,0
3,121,52,0,0,36.0,0.127,25,1
2,101,58,17,265,24.2,0.614,23,0
2,56,56,28,45,24.2,0.332,22,0
0,162,76,36,0,49.6,0.364,26,1
0,95,64,39,105,44.6,0.366,22,0
4,125,80,0,0,32.3,0.536,27,1
5,136,82,0,0,0.0,0.640,69,0
2,129,74,26,205,33.2,0.591,25,0
3,130,64,0,0,23.1,0.314,22,0
1,107,50,19,0,28.3,0.181,29,0
1,140,74,26,180,24.1,0.828,23,0
1,144,82,46,180,46.1,0.335,46,1
8,107,80,0,0,24.6,0.856,34,0
13,158,114,0,0,42.3,0.257,44,1
2,121,70,32,95,39.1,0.886,23,0
7,129,68,49,125,38.5,0.439,43,1
2,90,60,0,0,23.5,0.191,25,0
7,142,90,24,480,30.4,0.128,43,1
3,169,74,19,125,29.9,0.268,31,1
0,99,0,0,0,25.0,0.253,22,0
4,127,88,11,155,34.5,0.598,28,0
4,118,70,0,0,44.5,0.904,26,0
2,122,76,27,200,35.9,0.483,26,0
6,125,78,31,0,27.6,0.565,49,1
1,168,88,29,0,35.0,0.905,52,1
2,129,0,0,0,38.5,0.304,41,0
4,110,76,20,100,28.4,0.118,27,0
6,80,80,36,0,39.8,0.177,28,0
10,115,0,0,0,0.0,0.261,30,1
2,127,46,21,335,34.4,0.176,22,0
9,164,78,0,0,32.8,0.148,45,1
2,93,64,32,160,38.0,0.674,23,1
3,158,64,13,387,31.2,0.295,24,0
5,126,78,27,22,29.6,0.439,40,0
10,129,62,36,0,41.2,0.441,38,1
0,134,58,20,291,26.4,0.352,21,0
3,102,74,0,0,29.5,0.121,32,0
7,187,50,33,392,33.9,0.826,34,1
3,173,78,39,185,33.8,0.970,31,1
10,94,72,18,0,23.1,0.595,56,0
1,108,60,46,178,35.5,0.415,24,0
5,97,76,27,0,35.6,0.378,52,1
4,83,86,19,0,29.3,0.317,34,0
1,114,66,36,200,38.1,0.289,21,0
1,149,68,29,127,29.3,0.349,42,1
5,117,86,30,105,39.1,0.251,42,0
1,111,94,0,0,32.8,0.265,45,0
4,112,78,40,0,39.4,0.236,38,0
1,116,78,29,180,36.1,0.496,25,0
0,141,84,26,0,32.4,0.433,22,0
2,175,88,0,0,22.9,0.326,22,0
2,92,52,0,0,30.1,0.141,22,0
3,130,78,23,79,28.4,0.323,34,1
8,120,86,0,0,28.4,0.259,22,1
2,174,88,37,120,44.5,0.646,24,1
2,106,56,27,165,29.0,0.426,22,0
2,105,75,0,0,23.3,0.560,53,0
4,95,60,32,0,35.4,0.284,28,0
0,126,86,27,120,27.4,0.515,21,0
8,65,72,23,0,32.0,0.600,42,0
2,99,60,17,160,36.6,0.453,21,0
1,102,74,0,0,39.5,0.293,42,1
11,120,80,37,150,42.3,0.785,48,1
3,102,44,20,94,30.8,0.400,26,0
1,109,58,18,116,28.5,0.219,22,0
9,140,94,0,0,32.7,0.734,45,1
13,153,88,37,140,40.6,1.174,39,0
12,100,84,33,105,30.0,0.488,46,0
1,147,94,41,0,49.3,0.358,27,1
1,81,74,41,57,46.3,1.096,32,0
3,187,70,22,200,36.4,0.408,36,1
6,162,62,0,0,24.3,0.178,50,1
4,136,70,0,0,31.2,1.182,22,1
1,121,78,39,74,39.0,0.261,28,0
3,108,62,24,0,26.0,0.223,25,0
0,181,88,44,510,43.3,0.222,26,1
8,154,78,32,0,32.4,0.443,45,1
1,128,88,39,110,36.5,1.057,37,1
7,137,90,41,0,32.0,0.391,39,0
0,123,72,0,0,36.3,0.258,52,1
1,106,76,0,0,37.5,0.197,26,0
6,190,92,0,0,35.5,0.278,66,1
2,88,58,26,16,28.4,0.766,22,0
9,170,74,31,0,44.0,0.403,43,1
9,89,62,0,0,22.5,0.142,33,0
10,101,76,48,180,32.9,0.171,63,0
2,122,70,27,0,36.8,0.340,27,0
5,121,72,23,112,26.2,0.245,30,0
1,126,60,0,0,30.1,0.349,47,1
1,93,70,31,0,30.4,0.315,23,0
;run;
data class_0 class_1;
set diabetes;
if class=0 then output class_0;
else output class_1;
run;

data train;
set class_0(obs=100)
	class_1(obs=100);
run;

%let  
VAR_WANT = 
		age_n1h1,age_n2h1,age_n3h1,age_n4h1,age_n5h1,age_n6h1,age_n7h1,age_n8h1
		,
		bmi_n1h1,bmi_n2h1,bmi_n3h1,bmi_n4h1,bmi_n5h1,bmi_n6h1,bmi_n7h1,bmi_n8h1
		,
		dia_pedigree_n1h1,dia_pedigree_n2h1,dia_pedigree_n3h1,dia_pedigree_n4h1,dia_pedigree_n5h1,dia_pedigree_n6h1,dia_pedigree_n7h1,dia_pedigree_n8h1
		,
		diastolic_n1h1,diastolic_n2h1,diastolic_n3h1,diastolic_n4h1,diastolic_n5h1,diastolic_n6h1,diastolic_n7h1,diastolic_n8h1
		,
		insulin_n1h1,insulin_n2h1,insulin_n3h1,insulin_n4h1,insulin_n5h1,insulin_n6h1,insulin_n7h1,insulin_n8h1
		,
		nos_pregnant_n1h1,nos_pregnant_n2h1,nos_pregnant_n3h1,nos_pregnant_n4h1,nos_pregnant_n5h1,nos_pregnant_n6h1,nos_pregnant_n7h1,nos_pregnant_n8h1
		,
		plasma_n1h1,plasma_n2h1,plasma_n3h1,plasma_n4h1,plasma_n5h1,plasma_n6h1,plasma_n7h1,plasma_n8h1
		,
		triceps_n1h1,triceps_n2h1,triceps_n3h1,triceps_n4h1,triceps_n5h1,triceps_n6h1,triceps_n7h1,triceps_n8h1
		,
		n1h1_output,n2h1_output,n3h1_output,n4h1_output,n5h1_output,n6h1_output,n7h1_output,n8h1_output
		,b1
		,b2
;

%let inde_obs_want= nos_pregnant {OBS}, plasma {OBS}, diastolic 	{OBS}, triceps {OBS}, 
					insulin 	 {OBS}, bmi    {OBS}, dia_pedigree 	{OBS}, age {OBS} 	,
					class {OBS};
%let independent_variable=nos_pregnant plasma diastolic triceps insulin bmi dia_pedigree age;
%let target_variable=class;

%let print_want=
age_n1h1 age_n2h1 age_n3h1 age_n4h1 age_n5h1 age_n6h1 age_n7h1 age_n8h1 
bmi_n1h1 bmi_n2h1 bmi_n3h1 bmi_n4h1 bmi_n5h1 bmi_n6h1 bmi_n7h1 bmi_n8h1 

dia_pedigree_n1h1 dia_pedigree_n2h1 dia_pedigree_n3h1 dia_pedigree_n4h1 
dia_pedigree_n5h1 dia_pedigree_n6h1 dia_pedigree_n7h1 dia_pedigree_n8h1 

diastolic_n1h1 diastolic_n2h1 diastolic_n3h1 diastolic_n4h1 
diastolic_n5h1 diastolic_n6h1 diastolic_n7h1 diastolic_n8h1 

insulin_n1h1 insulin_n2h1 insulin_n3h1 insulin_n4h1 
insulin_n5h1 insulin_n6h1 insulin_n7h1 insulin_n8h1 

n1h1_output n2h1_output n3h1_output n4h1_output 
n5h1_output n6h1_output n7h1_output n8h1_output 

nos_pregnant_n1h1 nos_pregnant_n2h1 nos_pregnant_n3h1 nos_pregnant_n4h1 
nos_pregnant_n5h1 nos_pregnant_n6h1 nos_pregnant_n7h1 nos_pregnant_n8h1 

plasma_n1h1 plasma_n2h1 plasma_n3h1 plasma_n4h1 
plasma_n5h1 plasma_n6h1 plasma_n7h1 plasma_n8h1 

triceps_n1h1 triceps_n2h1 triceps_n3h1 triceps_n4h1 
triceps_n5h1 triceps_n6h1 triceps_n7h1 triceps_n8h1 
b1 b2;

%let wpath=/workspace/server/on/grid/folder;

ods output printtable=coefficient_dsn;
proc optmodel;
	var &var_want.;
	set OBS;
	number &inde_obs_want.	;;
	read data train into OBS=[_N_] &independent_variable. &target_variable.;

	/*Objective function gets called here. Leave 2 semicolons below*/
	%include "&wpath./formula.sas";;

	/*Constraint gets called here. Leave 2 semicolons below*/
	%include "&wpath./constraint.sas";;


	solve with nlp /ms;

	print &print_want.;
	;quit;

data match;
	/* Set one of your data sets, usually the larger data set */
	set train;
	do i=1 to n;
		/* For every observation in the first data set,    */
		/* read in each observation in the second data set */
		set coefficient_dsn point=i nobs=n;
		output;
	end;
run;

data temp_output;
set match;
n=_n_;
/*output=&equation_for_dsn.;*/
%include "&wpath./act_formula.sas";;*Leave 2 semicolons here;
run;

 

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
RobPratt
SAS Super FREQ

The issue is that the problem is probably infeasible.  The form of the problem is to minimize a sum-of-squares objective sum {i in OBS} (y[i] – a[i])^2 subject to equality constraints y[i] = a[i].  If these constraints were feasible, the optimal objective value would be 0.  Even running multistart in distributed mode on a grid with more than 100 workers, I was not able to find a feasible solution.  The constraints are not ignored but are difficult (probably impossible) to satisfy.  Both the iteration log and the Solution Summary report an Infeasibility of 0.5.  If I omit the constraints, the smallest objective value I get is 33.119976397, and the resulting variable values are not all 0.

View solution in original post

6 REPLIES 6
ballardw
Super User

If you are getting any warnings or note much more than number of observations used you might post the LOG with them.

david27
Quartz | Level 8

Please find the log and result in the attached files.

Please note: Only partial result has been put in the word doc.

RobPratt
SAS Super FREQ

The issue is that the problem is probably infeasible.  The form of the problem is to minimize a sum-of-squares objective sum {i in OBS} (y[i] – a[i])^2 subject to equality constraints y[i] = a[i].  If these constraints were feasible, the optimal objective value would be 0.  Even running multistart in distributed mode on a grid with more than 100 workers, I was not able to find a feasible solution.  The constraints are not ignored but are difficult (probably impossible) to satisfy.  Both the iteration log and the Solution Summary report an Infeasibility of 0.5.  If I omit the constraints, the smallest objective value I get is 33.119976397, and the resulting variable values are not all 0.

david27
Quartz | Level 8

 Hello @RobPratt 

 

Can we use optmodel or any other SAS/OR procedure where we can have such binary outputs--0 or 1?

In this example that i provided the Class variable has values like 0 or 1.

Do we have any similar example?

RobPratt
SAS Super FREQ

PROC OPTMODEL includes access to the mixed integer linear programming (MILP) solver, which support binary variables.

 

You might also be interested in this thread that illustrates using the quadratic programming (QP) solver to implement SVM.

david27
Quartz | Level 8

Thank You very much @RobPratt as always.

I don't know why i got so much hung up on having a constraint.

And thank you again for the additional reference for SVM.

I will study SVM and come back to you again on that probably. lol.

 

Regards

 

 

sas-innovate-2024.png

Available on demand!

Missed SAS Innovate Las Vegas? Watch all the action for free! View the keynotes, general sessions and 22 breakouts on demand.

 

Register now!

Multiple Linear Regression in SAS

Learn how to run multiple linear regression models with and without interactions, presented by SAS user Alex Chaplin.

Find more tutorials on the SAS Users YouTube channel.

Discussion stats
  • 6 replies
  • 933 views
  • 0 likes
  • 3 in conversation