BookmarkSubscribeRSS Feed
🔒 This topic is solved and locked. Need further help from the community? Please sign in and ask a new question.
niam
Quartz | Level 8

Hello;

I have a panel data set, some of the variables change over time, while some others don't. For example,

dependent variable is the number of publications by professors in each year which changes over time.

independent variable is the amount of research grants that a professor has per year, which also changes over time.

the other independent variable is the type university with which the professor is affiliated with (teaching vs research school), which does not change in my data set.

When I run a panel regression with fixed effect, I do not get any estimates for the university type, the university type effects are only only estimated in the random effects model. However, I know that in addition to the university type, there are some characteristics that pertain to professors and do not change over time which I have not been able to measure and thus theoretically I need to run a fixed effects model.

Is there any way to keep the university type as a variable which does not change over time and still run a fixed effects model?

Thanks

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
ets_kps
SAS Employee

Hi Niam,

Thanks for your question.  You seem to have two distinct wants for your model. The first, and your primary research question seems to be whether funding influences publications.  If that is the case, then your FE estimate with the university type dropped is effectively controlling for the university type and all other idiosyncratic confounding effects specific to the professor.  So your estimates, assuming the modeling specified correctly, should be consistent.

If you are interested in the marginal effect of type and you want to still control for some idiosyncratic professor effect, you will need to relax some of the assumptions on the way that university type interacts with professor specific effects.  If willing to do this, you can employ another estimator known as a Hausman-Taylor estimator. Currently we do not have super convenient access to this estimator in ETS (but look for it soon Smiley Happy).  In the meantime, if you look at this document, page 210 http://eco.cueb.edu.cn/upload/2012/9/616432590.pdf

then you will see how to estimate this in SAS.  It is a multistep process.  You can also find IML code here.


Copyright C 2012 by R. Carter Hill and Randall C. Campbell
"Using SAS for Econometrics"
    by R. Carter Hill and Randall C. Campbell (2012)
    John Wiley and Sons, Inc
 

Chapter 15


Again, the key assumption for this model to make sense is that there is no correlation between the individual professor characteristics and the university type (which seems a little implausible to me though this is your call)        

Best of luck-Ken     

View solution in original post

3 REPLIES 3
udo_sas
SAS Employee

Hello -

This recording might be of interest: Panel Data Models in SAS - YouTube

Thanks,

Udo

ets_kps
SAS Employee

Hi Niam,

Thanks for your question.  You seem to have two distinct wants for your model. The first, and your primary research question seems to be whether funding influences publications.  If that is the case, then your FE estimate with the university type dropped is effectively controlling for the university type and all other idiosyncratic confounding effects specific to the professor.  So your estimates, assuming the modeling specified correctly, should be consistent.

If you are interested in the marginal effect of type and you want to still control for some idiosyncratic professor effect, you will need to relax some of the assumptions on the way that university type interacts with professor specific effects.  If willing to do this, you can employ another estimator known as a Hausman-Taylor estimator. Currently we do not have super convenient access to this estimator in ETS (but look for it soon Smiley Happy).  In the meantime, if you look at this document, page 210 http://eco.cueb.edu.cn/upload/2012/9/616432590.pdf

then you will see how to estimate this in SAS.  It is a multistep process.  You can also find IML code here.


Copyright C 2012 by R. Carter Hill and Randall C. Campbell
"Using SAS for Econometrics"
    by R. Carter Hill and Randall C. Campbell (2012)
    John Wiley and Sons, Inc
 

Chapter 15


Again, the key assumption for this model to make sense is that there is no correlation between the individual professor characteristics and the university type (which seems a little implausible to me though this is your call)        

Best of luck-Ken     

niam
Quartz | Level 8

Thank you very much. Your references address my question.

Best

sas-innovate-2024.png

 

Time is running out to save with the early bird rate. Register by Friday, March 1 for just $695 - $100 off the standard rate.

 

Check out the agenda and get ready for a jam-packed event featuring workshops, super demos, breakout sessions, roundtables, inspiring keynotes and incredible networking events. 

 

Register now!

Multiple Linear Regression in SAS

Learn how to run multiple linear regression models with and without interactions, presented by SAS user Alex Chaplin.

Find more tutorials on the SAS Users YouTube channel.

Discussion stats
  • 3 replies
  • 1884 views
  • 3 likes
  • 3 in conversation