Programming the statistical procedures from SAS

glimmix: binary logistic regression model - interpretation of residual plots

Reply
Contributor
Posts: 51

glimmix: binary logistic regression model - interpretation of residual plots

Hello all!

In a generalized linear mixed model ( http://communities.sas.com/message/104264#104264 ) I have used the plots= option (studentpanel pearsonpanel) to display residual diagnotics and check the assumptions of normality and homoscedasticity.

I do not quite know how to interpret the upper left plot where pearson residuals are plotted against the linear predictors (linear scale). When I googled on this topic, some sources say that model deviations cannot be seen in such a diagram unless the curves are smoothed by an appropriate method.

Hm, with a binary response variable, how is the plot supposed to look like ?

PearsonPanelconditional.png

When I include a quadratic effect of the covariate (cf. glimmix code via link provided above), the panels look quite similar; the quadratic effect is significant, but the model fit does hardly change.

PearsonPanelconditional-quadratic.png

Thank you for any help, or readings to help me understand residual diagnostics in logistic regression.

Valued Guide
Valued Guide
Posts: 684

glimmix: binary logistic regression model - interpretation of residual plots

This has come up a few times in this Discussion Forum. With purely binary response (0/1), the usual residual-diagnositic plots are not very useful. Books such as Collett (Modelling Binary Data) disucss this in some detail. There are more specialized graphs, but these are not part of the usual ODS graphics output. The upper left graph is caused by the fact the the response has only two possible values, but the predicted values are continuous. If you just consider the 0s, then you get one of those curves of points as the predictor (x) varies over the full range. Likewise, if you consider the 1s, you get the other curve of points. In other words, this graph does not tell you if the model is appropriate or not.

Contributor
Posts: 51

glimmix: binary logistic regression model - interpretation of residual plots

Thanks very much for the facts.

What kind of diagnostic graphs would be necessary to find out if the model is appropriate ?

Does SAS have any detailed information on that topic too ? I would be grateful for any help.

Ask a Question
Discussion stats
  • 2 replies
  • 1074 views
  • 3 likes
  • 2 in conversation