topic Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS in Statistical Procedures

Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

mszommer — Sun, 26 Feb 2017 20:37:39 GMT

Hello,

I have a non metric DV (ordinal) and both metric and non metric Independent variables and need to classify /predict group membership.

I know that PROC DISCRIM uses only continuous variables in the VAR Statement. How can I run a multiple discriminant analysis in SAS

Any help would be more than appreciated

Regards,

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

Ksharp — Thu, 23 Feb 2017 11:23:57 GMT

I don't know what you mean by " multiple discriminant analysis in SAS"

For predict model, most used is

1) proc logistic

2) proc hpsplit --- decision tree

Discriminant is very low powerful, and only can apply to continuous variables.

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

mszommer — Thu, 23 Feb 2017 14:36:44 GMT

Well, linear discriminant analysis requires continuous independent variables, however multiple discriminant analysis works with a metric dependent variable and non metric independent variables.

I'm looking at predicting group membership.

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

PaigeMiller — Thu, 23 Feb 2017 16:22:27 GMT

@mszommer wrote:

Well, linear discriminant analysis requires continuous independent variables, however multiple discriminant analysis works with a metric dependent variable and non metric independent variables.

I think you have it backwards. Multiple discriminant analysis would have several class dependent variables, and metric independent variables. However, SAS PROC DISCRIM does not perform Multiple discriminant analysis, it only works on a single dependent variable.

If you really have multiple dependent class variables, you could combine them into a single class variable encompassing all of the multiple class variables, or perhaps something like PROC PLS will work (or maybe it won't, I haven't really tried).

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

mszommer — Sat, 25 Feb 2017 20:50:28 GMT

Hello Paige,

I have just one dependent variable (rating of delivery: ordinal) and varied non metric (nominal, ordinal) and metric (discrete) independent variables.

I wish to classify the respondents based on their delivery rating. What test would you suggest?

Regards

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

PaigeMiller — Thu, 23 Feb 2017 18:18:46 GMT

@mszommer wrote:

Hello Paige,

I have just one dependent variable (rating of delivery: ordinal) and varied non metric (nominal, ordinal) and metric (discrete) independent variables.

This contradicts everything you have previously stated ... now you have one dependent variable that is ordinal. Is this the correct statement of the problem now?

I wish to classify the respondents based on their delivery rating. What test would you suggest?

Did you mean to say you want to classify the respondents based upon their independent variables?

If your answer to both questions above is YES, then I think PROC DISCRIM is fine, or logistic regression would also be a tool that can be used in this situation.

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

PGStats — Thu, 23 Feb 2017 20:41:14 GMT

mszommer wrote:
I have just one dependent variable (rating of delivery: ordinal) and varied non metric (nominal, ordinal) and metric (discrete) independent variables.

Given the nature of your predictors, I think you should at least consider @Ksharp's suggestion to use (a recent version of) HPSPLIT. A decision tree model is easier to interpret than discriminant or logistic models and relies on fewer assumptions about the predictors.

If you have access to JMP, try the Partition platform to develop your decision tree. It's a lot easier to use.

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

mszommer — Sat, 25 Feb 2017 20:50:01 GMT

Thank you all for your response. I really appreciate it.

I did run PROC HPSPLIT, however, I have difficulties interpreting the results. Could you kindly help with it?

Also, I do not have access to JMP.

Regards

Re: Multiple Discriminant Analysis: SAS

PGStats — Sat, 25 Feb 2017 22:37:45 GMT

I only have access to version 13.1 of SAS/STAT. From what I can read, proc HPSPLIT is much friendlier in version 14.1. I suggest you ask for help on HPSPLIT as a new topic. Good luck!