topic Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression in Statistical Procedures

Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

user24feb — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 11:19:46 GMT

Hello,

How can I get the AIC's of all models of stepwise regression? If I use this code, I only get the result for the final model:

Data Input (Drop=i j);

Array X{*} X1-X500;

Do j=1 To 140;

X1=Rannor(1);

X2=Rannor(1);

Y=2+X1*3-X2*4+Rannor(1)-0.5;

Do i=3 To 500;

X{i}=Rannor(1);

End;

Output;

End;

Run;

Proc Reg Data=Input OutEst=Result;

Model Y = X1-X500 / Selection=Forward AIC BIC;

Run;

Thanks & kind regards

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

JacobSimonsen — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 11:49:50 GMT

You can try use PROC HPGENSELECT.


proc hpgenselect data=input;
Model Y = X1-X50/dist=normal link=id;
Selection method=forward(choose=aic);
Run;

It shows the AIC value from each model. It also choose the model based on the AIC. Unfortunately I couldn't get it to work with 500 variables (error message due to resource problems) so I only included the first 50 variables.

Effect Number p

Step Entered Effects In AIC Value

0 Intercept 1 877.2496 .

------------------------------------------------------------

1 x2 2 760.4677 <.0001

2 x1 3 413.6365 <.0001

3 x39 4 406.7601 0.0034

4 x47 5 400.3529 0.0043

5 x17 6 395.3228* 0.0088

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

user24feb — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 12:11:08 GMT

I'm sorry for the typos in my code. If I copy-paste something (I think including squiggly brackets), the editor kind of "self-destructs".

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

data_null__ — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 12:20:20 GMT

ods output SelParmEst=SelParmEst;

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

plf515 — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 12:22:00 GMT

You shouldn't be using stepwise to build models - the results are wrong see e.g. Stopping Stepwise

However, if you still want this, you can use GLMSELECT and use the DETAILS = FITSTATISTICS on the MODEL statement.

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

FreelanceReinh — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 12:34:11 GMT

Here's sample code for PROC GLMSELECT:

proc glmselect data=input;
model y = x1-x5 / selection=forward(select=sl) stats=bic details=all;
run;

The sub-option SELECT=SL specifies that variable selection is based on the significance level of the F statistic (similar to PROC REG, the default would be different: SBC). Option STATS=BIC includes the BIC in the output. AIC is included by default. DETAILS=ALL requests fit statistics and many other details about the models at each step of the variable selection process.

I've reduced the number of independent variables to 5 just for demonstration. Having more explanatory effects (500) than observations (140) in the analysis dataset would not be sensible for the general linear model anyway.

Re: Get statistics (AIC's) of all models of a stepwise regression

JacobSimonsen — Tue, 01 Mar 2016 13:30:24 GMT

@plf515
I agree partly ...and also disagree partly...
Stepwise method have tendency to include too many variables. But, if it is clear when the results is reported that the associations was found by model section and not by testing well defined hypthoses, then there is no problem. Or, if the variable selection is done on a training dataset to generate hypothis, which then is tested on an other dataset it is also a valid approach.