topic Re: How to write SAS code about this combination in SAS Programming

HELP PLEASE--how to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 16:01:07 GMT

A portion of my data is as in the attachment. In the attachment, there are three items, "key" is item key, COL1 to COL3 are the responses of three candidates to those three items. I want to choose any pair from three candidates, then compare the responses of each pair with the "key". COL12, COL13, COL23 are the results I wanted. Following are the simple SAS code to create COL12 variable.

data want;

set have;

if COL1=COL2=key then COL12="same resp and both correct";

else if COL1=COL2 and COL1^=key then COL12="same resp and both wrong";
else if COL1=COL2 and COL2^=key then COL12="same resp and both wrong";

else if COL1=key then COL12="different resp and one of them correct";
else if COL2=key then COL12="different resp and one of them correct";

else COL12="different resp and both wrong";

run;

Because I have many 52 columns, so the combinations of each pair would be C(52,2)=52!.(52-2)!2!=1326. Any quick way to help me get what I wanted?

PLEASE HELP!

thank you!

How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 14:42:12 GMT

As data in the attachment. I have 250 items , "key" is the key of each item, COL1 to COL52 are the responses of 52 candidates to those 250 items. I want to choose any pair from those 52 candidates, that is, C(52, 2)=52!/(52-2)!2!, and compare the responses of EACH PAIR with the "key" . For example,

data comb1;

set comb;

if COL1=COL2=key then category="same resp and both correct";

else if COL1=COL2 and COL1^=key then category="same resp and both wrong";
else if COL1=COL2 and COL2^=key then category="same resp and both wrong";

else if COL1=key then category="different resp and one of them correct";
else if COL2=key then category="different resp and one of them correct";

else category="different resp and both wrong";

run;

Because C(52, 2)=52! / (52-2)!2! = 1326 pairs, for each pair, I want to use the code above, how should I do it in SAS?

thank you!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

PeterClemmensen — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 14:50:52 GMT

@superbug in problems like this, it is always easier to solve a smaller problem, which resembles your actual problem and then scale up.

Suppose your data looks like this

data have;
input itempos key COL1-COL3;
infile datalines dlm=',';
datalines;
1,1,3,3,1
2,3,3,3,3
3,1,1,1,1
;

What do you want the result to look like?

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 15:06:10 GMT

@PeterClemmensen

use the small data you suggested, I'd like the result to be as in the attachment (have.csv). thank you!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

PeterClemmensen — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 15:12:58 GMT

Why do you want to do this? As you point out yourself, this will require 52 choose 2 = 1326 = too many new variables in your original problem.

It can be done fairly simple, but it is not advisable. It seems like a part of a bigger problem so what do you want to do with the new variables?

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 15:21:53 GMT

@PeterClemmensen

under each pair, there are different categories on the responses compared with the key. I want to get the freq of the categories in each pair.

you said "It can be done fairly simple, but it is not advisable", could you please let me know your simple way?

thanks!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

novinosrin — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 17:11:18 GMT

Hi @superbug See if this helps,


data have;
input itempos key COL1-COL3;
infile datalines dlm=',';
datalines;
1,1,3,3,1
2,3,3,3,3
3,1,1,1,1
;


data want;
 set have;
 array c col:;
 length category $30 Pair $20;
 do _i=1 to dim(c)-1;
  do _j=_i+1 to dim(c);
   k1=c(_i);
   k2=c(_j);
   Pair=catx('_','Pair',_i,_j);
   if k1=k2=key then category="same resp and both wrong";
   else if k1=k2^=key then category="same resp and both wrong";
   else if k1=key or k2=key then category="different resp and one of them correct";
   output;
  end;
 end;
 keep itempos key category pair;
run;
proc transpose data=want out=final_want(drop=_:);
by itempos key notsorted;
var category;
id pair;
run;

Feel free to let us know if you need any clarifications. All the best!

Re: HELP PLEASE--how to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 16:01:56 GMT

oops, here is the file.

Re: HELP PLEASE--how to write SAS code about this combination

novinosrin — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 16:03:29 GMT

Seems like you reposted a duplicate of https://communities.sas.com/t5/SAS-Programming/How-to-write-SAS-code-about-this-combination/m-p/625610

My apologies if my solution didn't work for you.

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 16:25:33 GMT

@novinosrin

your solution worked!

Thank you so much! give you a big thumb up!!

Because I was so eager to get correct solutions in my previous post, while I was waiting for help, I reposted it before I get your correct solution.

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

novinosrin — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 16:36:01 GMT

@superbug No worries, No matter what, there is never a need to duplicate for the simple reason 1. often confuses which one to respond to 2. Ethically doesn't go well 3. Yes I fully understand, sometimes the requirement is urgent and can get us panicky, however still better to stick to one and wait.

Trust me, there are about 30+ of us who will respond and will attempt to offer the much needed solution. Particularly on gaming alike these kinda questions we treat this as fun. For a rather advisory role, I don't but on the other hand I seek and take advice from senior people like @Reeza (Thanking Reeza for merging the thread).

So either way, you have it all. Just be patient for one of the 30+ mentioned to respond, and on top of that a new person outside of the expected 30+ has surprised many a times.

All the best! Take care and have fun!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

PeterClemmensen — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 18:34:50 GMT

Sure

data _null_;
   length vars $ 20000;
   do i=1 to 52-1;
      do j=i+1 to 52;
         vars = catx(' ', vars, cats('pair_', i, '_', j));
      end;
   end;
   call symputx('vars', vars);
run;

data want(keep=itempos key pair:);
   set have;
   array c {*} col:;
   array p {1326} $ 50 &vars.;
   do i=1 to 52-1;
      do j=i+1 to 52;
         idx=sum(idx, 1);
         if       c[i]=c[j]=key    then p[idx] = "same resp and both wrong";
         else if  c[i]=c[j] ne key then p[idx] = "same resp and both wrong";
         else if  i=key | j=key    then p[idx] = "different resp and one of them correct";
         else                           p[idx] = "different resp and both wrong";
      end;
   end;
run;

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 18:09:00 GMT

@PeterClemmensen

it worked!

Thanks much for your reply!

I very much appreciate your time and help!!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 18:33:40 GMT

@novinosrin

You SAS expert / masters are so amazing! I feel so fortunate to join the SAS support community recently.

A follow up problem need your help.

After I get those1326 pairs, I use the following to get freq on the category of each pair

proc freq data=final_want;
table Pair_:/out=freq;
run;

I got the freq tables in the "Results Viewer". For example, "pair_1_2" looks like following

Pair_1_2	Frequency	Percent	Cumulative Frequency	Cumulative Percent
different resp and both wrong	35	17.50	35	17.50
different resp and one of them	37	18.50	72	36.00
same resp and both correct	118	59.00	190	95.00
same resp and both wrong	10	5.00	200	100.00

since each pair has a freq table, could you please let me know how to stack all of those freq table? Then using the stacked freq table, I want to divided "frequency" by 149, and get a "new_pct" variable, the results I wanted will look like the following:

	category	freq		pct_new
	different resp and both wrong	35	149	0.23
	different resp and one of them	37	149	0.25
pair_1_2	same resp and both correct	118	149	0.79
	same resp and both wrong	10	149	0.07
	different resp and both wrong	42	149	0.28

pari_1_3	different resp and one of them	34	149	0.23
	same resp and both correct	114	149	0.77
	same resp and both wrong	10	149	0.07

Many thanks!!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

novinosrin — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 18:43:18 GMT

Hi @superbug That looks like you want a Tabulated report(cross) report. Am i correct? If yes, the leads to the utilization of PROC TABULATE / PROC REPORT . If this understanding of mine is correct, You are better off starting a new thread mentioning what you HAVE (the outcome of proc freq) and the report design structure you want.

That would make it easy for your to follow and for respondents to offer pointed answers. People like Ballardw , Reeza are super proficient in Report procedures while I am mostly into video games(aka programming) . Makes sense?

PS Always make sure your IF THENs are properly tested with solutions I offer in this or any other thread because sometimes I write so fast making me a typo champion. lol

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Tue, 18 Feb 2020 19:09:28 GMT

@novinosrin

Thanks much for your advice!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Sun, 14 Jun 2020 17:54:30 GMT

@novinosrin

a while ago, you help about pick a 2 people from a certain number of people. Now if I want to choose 4 people from a certain number of people, I am trying to modify the code you help, but there are error messages, could you help please. Below is the code for pick 4 people from a certain number of people. Thanks much!

data comb1;
set comb;
array c col:;
length cat $30 Pair $20;
do _i=1 to dim(c)-1;
do _j=_i+1 to dim(c);
do _m=_j+1 to dim(c)+1;
do _n=_m+1 to dim(c)+2;
k1=c(_i);
k2=c(_j);
k3=c(_m);
k4=c(_n);
Pair=catx('_','Pair',_i,_j,_m,_n);
if k1=k2=k3=k4=itemkey then cat="same resp and all correct";
else if k1=k2=k3=k4^=itemkey then cat="same resp and all wrong";
else if _i=itemkey or _j=itemkey or _m=itemkey or _n=itemkey then cat="different resp and one of them correct";
else cat="different resp and all wrong";
output;
end;
end;
end;
end;
keep itempos itemkey cat pair;
run;

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

novinosrin — Sun, 14 Jun 2020 19:39:04 GMT

Hi @superbug Pleasure is and would be mine if i could help. If it's not urgent, can you hang in there till tomorrow EST (US time ) as I'm doing the weekend chores like laundry and cleaning at the moment. Stay safe

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Sun, 14 Jun 2020 20:16:42 GMT

@novinosrin

Thank you for replying my post. Sorry for bothering you on the weekend. Of course I'll wait until you are available.

Enjoy doing the weekend chores.

Stay safe!

Re: How to write SAS code about this combination

superbug — Mon, 15 Jun 2020 20:53:28 GMT

@novinosrin

Thanks much for the explanation and teaching!

very much appreciate your help!