topic Interactive Binning Node vs. Transformation Node Binning in SAS Data Science

Interactive Binning Node vs. Transformation Node Binning

GalacticAbacus — Wed, 06 Sep 2017 17:23:26 GMT

Hi,

I'm interested in comparing the Transformation node vs. the Interactive Binning Node.

What is the difference between setting the interval-inputs setting to "optimal binning" for a variable vs. using the interactive binning node?

Let's say I'm using the Transformation node and I've selected the interval-inputs to "optimal", and based on chi-squared a couple of my variables have been selected for binning transformation. Is there a benefit to tagging on the Interactive Binning Node downstream to assess optimal binning once transformation is assessed?

I'm assuming it's still of use as some of my variables transformed via log or non-binning transformation could still be considered downstream for binning once normality is addressed... so binning is only redundant if a variable was binned via transformation and then re-binned with the binnning node?

I'd appreciate clarification of any misunderstanding I may have.

Re: Interactive Binning Node vs. Transformation Node Binning

WendyCzika — Thu, 07 Sep 2017 00:28:18 GMT

Those 2 nodes just give you different methods for binning, so you would just use one of those nodes for binning, based on whatever method you want to use. Optimal binning in Transform node takes the target into account to come up with the best bins, while in Interactive Binning, your options are to do either bucket or quantile binning (which don't use the target), then you can interactively modify those bins. Once the variables are binned, via either node, they are no longer interval, so you wouldn't bin those again, but as you said, you could still bin a variable after it's been log-transformed for example and is still interval. Hope that helps!

Re: Interactive Binning Node vs. Transformation Node Binning

GalacticAbacus — Thu, 07 Sep 2017 14:27:50 GMT

Yes it does help, thank you much!

Re: Interactive Binning Node vs. Transformation Node Binning

AnshulS — Mon, 25 Jun 2018 07:17:03 GMT

Thank you for your reply, which one will you prefer to use for Credit Risk - Probability of Default Model (if I do not have Interactive Grouping node in my SAS EM tool.